The way it should be

Looking for your 1099s?  Click here!

Consumer First Title & Escrow, LLC

428 McLaws Circle, Suite 202A Phone: (757) 645-4137

Williamsburg, VA.  23185 Fax: (757) 645-4187

Consumer First Title & Escrow was created to provide consumers, lenders, and realtors with a company they could trust to get the job done on time and accurately.  With experienced underwriters, processors, closers and title examiners, our company is committed to providing exceptional service to all the real estate and title needs of our customers.

When opening our office we knew it was important to have the communications and technologies that people demand in today's busy lifestyles.  Our staff is always willing to help you on the phone, by email or in person.  

Over the years our staff has built customer loyalty through exemplary customer service and knowing that we are there to help them every step of the way.

Our mission is to become a "trusted" companion to all in the real estate and title industry.  If you are a repeat customer or a first time home buyer we are here to not only help you get through your transaction but also to have you find a company who truly cares about you, the customer.

Visit us anytime!
Located on McLaws Circle on the second floor of the Wells Fargo building, our location is convenient and easy to get to from Interstate 64.  Visit our About Us page for driving directions and map. 

Stop by to meet us and get all your questions answered.

Or use the form on our Contact Us page to reach out to us or request a quote.
The combined knowledge and experience of our team members will ensure that you'll be well taken care of during your real estate experience.  We can answer, or find the answer to any of your questions. 

We can also assist you in obtaining a survey, termite inspection, HOA disclosure packages & dues, and other services/inspections that are needed at closing.


  • Founded in 1907, Old Republic has over a century of financial strength and stability.
  • The Old Republic Title Insurance Group* has been the highest overall rated title insurer for the last 20 years.